How to Avoid Negligent Hiring Claims

Back to blog
Posted by: David Garcia April 14, 2023

As an employer, your primary responsibility is the safety of your customers and your employees. An essential component of this duty is performing due diligence when hiring.

If you fail to adequately screen an employee who goes on to harm a third party — such as a customer or fellow worker — you may face a negligent hiring claim. And that can end up costing you and your business dearly.

If you’re unaware of the potential negative impact of negligent hiring, you’re in the right place.

This guide will take you through the definition of negligent hiring, how to prevent it, and what risks could emerge from cutting corners during the recruitment stage.

First, let’s start with the basics.

What Is Negligent Hiring?

Negligent hiring is a legal claim that an employee or customer can file if they’ve been harmed by an employee and if they believe the harmful behavior could have been predicted based on the background of the employee before they were hired. Some examples include:

  • An employee with a violent past assaults another member of staff
  • A home health care worker with a record of theft steals from an elderly patient

One of the biggest payouts in the United States was made by a communications company to the family of an elderly woman murdered in her own home by a service technician with a well-documented history of criminal behavior

The employers should’ve foreseen these events, either because they knew about the employee’s past or they should have known but failed in their due diligence. Negligent hiring leads to lawsuits.

How to Avoid Negligent Hiring Claims

There are a number of practices businesses can employ to avoid negligent hiring concerns. Here are a few examples:

  1. 1. Standardize your recruitment process to maintain consistency.
  2. 2. Verify resume details to uncover any discrepancies.
  3. 3. Ask insightful interview questions that assess candidate integrity and suitability.
  4. 4. Evaluate skills with comprehensive assessments to ensure qualifications.
  5. 5. Check references thoroughly and recognize potential red flags.
  6. 6. Conduct in-depth background checks for every applicant.

Create a Rigorous Recruitment Process

An employer’s HR team must create a robust recruitment process to make it difficult for applicants to disguise or omit information about themselves that’s relevant to the hiring decision.

Basically, when you’re applying for a job, the employer can’t just discriminate against you or ask for personal information that’s not relevant to the job. Ask certain questions, and you could be breaking the law.

A good example of legislation that impacts recruitment is ban-the-box laws and fair chance laws, created to help those with criminal records avoid discrimination during the hiring process.

Conduct Thorough Background Checks

Plenty of people put false information on their resume. It might not pertain to a claim for negligent hiring further down the line, but what else might they be hiding if they’re not being honest over some details?

It’s essential to take time to make thorough checks of applicants and also conduct the appropriate types of checks depending on the role and industry. This could include identity verification, reference checks, criminal history checks, and more.

Assess Job Relevant Competencies

Roles in specific sectors like financial services, education, and healthcare require professional training and licensing.

Industry-specific governing bodies verify training and look at other aspects of candidates’ suitability before issuing a professional license.

Always verify an applicant’s professional license: never take them at their word.

Employment involving transportation, whether a company car, a sandwich delivery business, or driving big rigs from coast to coast, should spark an MVR check for an applicant’s driving history.

The Importance of Comprehensive Background Checks

Comprehensive background checks are necessary for lots of reasons. Even with a detailed application form, essential candidate information is sometimes missed; that’s why professional pre-employment background screening is vital. These checks offer a lot of information and benefits to the employer.

Here are just a few reasons why.

  • Fraud Prevention: Discover fake education or employment details and even applicants using false identities.
  • Applicant Suitability: Check employment references and history.
  • Protect Investors and Customers: Uncover applicants with a history of fraud or who pose a financial risk.
  • Comply with Legislation and Industry-Specific Regulations: Protect the business from future legal action.

Exercising Due Diligence for All Candidates

Employers should carry out due diligence on all applicants; otherwise, they run the risk of being accused of discrimination.

Due diligence must comply with legislation on employment practices and hiring. It must be fair, reasonable, and ethical. Any background checks must also be relevant and proportionate to the type and seniority of the job.

Smaller organizations that don’t use professional background-checking services should create a defined process for all applicants to avoid an unfair piecemeal approach.

It can be necessary to conduct specific checks for certain roles. The check must be consistent with the vacancy and carried out on all candidates.

How Negligent Hiring Can Affect Your Business

Taking precautions in the hiring process is essential, or you could end up with some serious consequences – in addition to the harm the employee may cause, negligent hiring lawsuits can be extremely costly.

Not only that, but your reputation could also suffer as a result of wrongful hiring. It’s essential to take the time to verify that you’re hiring the right person for the job.

Final Thoughts

Negligent hiring can result in harm being done and even costly lawsuits – and it could potentially damage your reputation. Fortunately, there are steps you can take to avoid negligent hiring, including comprehensive background checks.

Professional background screening services offer employers many benefits, including avoiding a negligent hire claim. They protect businesses and take some of the legwork out of the recruitment process. Consider ScoutLogic today to help you find the perfect fit for your next hire.

Latest blog posts
May 04, 2024
What Is a Peer Interview?
A peer interview is a good tool to assess your candidate. These can be conducted formally or informally and indicate whether or not the new candidate will fit into your already...
May 02, 2024
What Is a Level 2 Background Check?
If you’re starting the recruitment process, you may be required to perform a Level 2 background check on any potential employee. However, many recruiters are unaware of the...
May 01, 2024
What Is Human Resource Management?
Anyone who has ever been a part of a company or organization has probably had some contact with people from the human resources department. HR is something of a black box to people...
April 30, 2024
How To Screen Resumes
When a new position opens up, hundreds of people will apply for the coveted spot. Hours can fly by while recruiting, just sorting resumes into piles of “no,” “yes,” and...
April 30, 2024
Recruiting Gen Z
As Gen Zers begin to make their way into the workforce, it can be challenging to understand this new generation, and recruiters can often struggle to enlist Gen Z...
Looking for a better background check company? Start by preparing with this free guide.

Download this free guide to go into the searching process prepared. This guide includes actionable steps to:

  • Gather your requirements
  • Determine vendors
  • Check references
  • Determine success metrics
get a free e-book

Get a free e-book